Child’s broken ribs ‘evidence of abuse’
Last updated at 15:25, Tuesday, 09 November 2010
A YOUNGSTER’S injuries were consistent with being shaken, the jury in a child abuse trial has heard.
A medical expert giving evidence at the trial of a man accused of abusing a young child has described how a brain injury was caused by the child being shaken and not by “rough or clumsy” handling.
Dr Ian Mecrow, a consultant paediatrician with more than 20 years’ experience, had examined all the medical evidence on the young child that Christopher Newton is accused of abusing.
He told the jury yesterday at Preston Crown Court that the injuries received by the child were signs of deliberate abuse. The court heard that when the child was taken to Furness General Hospital by hospital last year, doctors found a brain injury, broken ribs and a broken toe.
Dr Mecrow said the brain injury would have happened just a few minutes before the 999 call was made. He also claimed broken ribs were “almost always” caused deliberately.
He said: “In research by the Welsh Study Group rib fractures came out as probably the most important pointer towards abuse injuries, particularly in very small children. A study by Bullock in America looked at children with rib fractures and concluded that they are almost always abusive injuries if there is no accident or underlying bone disease.”
Mr Roderick Priestley, prosecuting, asked Dr Mecrow: “Could clumsy or rough handling explain these injuries?”
“No,” the doctor replied.
The jury also heard that whoever had inflicted the injuries would have known they had hurt the child.
Dr Mecrow, who said he had dealt with around 50 cases of child abuse in the last two years, said: “Rib fractures are extremely painful. The person who did this would have known they had hurt the child. have been caused by being shaken or by being hit with a hard object.
When asked if the injury could have been caused by a fall, Dr Mecrow said: “It would be very, very rare in accidental falls.”
During cross-examination by defence barrister Mr Richard Vardon, Dr Mecrow conceded he was making certain conclusions about the child’s injuries based on the statements of its carers.
He said: “I am dependent on the statements of the people who were present at the time.”
Newton, 23, formerly of Barrow but now living at Myrtle Road, Trafford, Manchester, denies two charges of child cruelty and one charge of causing grievous bodily harm.
The trial continues with Newton expected to give evidence today.
First published at 14:19, Tuesday, 02 November 2010
Published by http://www.nwemail.co.uk
More Windermere news
- Windermere woman, 19, recalls horror Africa waterfall plunge
- Renowned Lake District hotel sold
- Parking meter anger "behind Cumbria by-election swing"
- Ulverston swimmer triumphs at Windermere Chillswim
- Woman attacked in Windermere
- South Lakes worker stole lottery tickets worth £4,000 to feed habit
- Yes vote on Scottish independence ‘could have massive effect’ on Cumbria businesses (2 comments)
- More experts join hunt for clues into Lake District wedding inferno (3 comments)
- Lake District hotel sold to local businessman
- Windermere school bully bites victim’s nose at club
- Woman involved in Windermere crash had been drinking - court heard
- South Lakes MP and deputy prime minister lead tributes to ‘dedicated’ Cumbria councillor (1 comment)
- ‘Nothing we can do’ say Lakes chiefs in parking meter row
- Cumbria police investigating after £25,000 damage to trees (2 comments)
- Swimmers make a big splash at Windermere
- Alleged sex offender due in Barrow court
- Peter Rabbit grabs gold at Chelsea Flower Show (1 comment)
- Brathay Windermere Marathon
- Fire at Lake District home
- Police appeal to trace owners of dogs who attacked lambs in Cumbria
- Queuing traffic on Lake District road
- Mum's emotional tribute son found in Windermere
- Matthew Jordan's family issue thanks to people who helped in Windermere search (4 comments)
- Cumbria police CCTV appeal for possible witness in search for man last seen in Bowness
- Family appeal for 20-year-old missing son last seen in Windermere to come home
Evening Mail homepage
Post 16 education
Go green 36
The Barber's Shop
Choosing a primary school